Topic: Altering images ultimately changes the
meaning of the original work. When a work represents “reality” do you think it
is ethical to alter an image to change its meaning from the work's original
context? In what ways do you believe this plays a part in Ken-Gonzales-Day’s
works, The
Bone Grass Boy: The Secret Banks of the Conejos River and Untitled
#36 (pp.36-37)?
Ultimately,
it depends on the purpose of the alteration; otherwise I’d say that completely
changing the meaning from the original work is not ethical. The fact that it
could be changed to any meaning, including the direct opposite of the original
ruins the purpose. For example, say if a piece was for just aesthetical looks,
but someone else took that art and used it in a marketing design, then it not
only does it not benefit the original artist, but the other person is making
money without trying.
However
with works like Ken Gonzales-Day, one can look toward an entirely new meaning
from the piece with just a touch of added content. The fact that everyone is
different, each of us can conjure up a multitude of perspectives; it all
depends on what we individually think on what makes “reality”. It can be from uncovering
the disgusting actions of people such as racism, sexism, or pollution, to
identifying stereotypes, television tropes, and pop culture.
In today’s
world, we have access to photo manipulating software like photoshop and GIMP,
and although they may be fun things to do, depending on the audience that views
the end product can produce a false reality. Take for instance, ads in
magazines that feature models, not all of them are “picture perfect”, they are
made that way through photo manipulation. This in turn can give people a false
standard at which they need to look at. In other instances, some pieces can be
easily spotted as photo manipulated especially if filters, and other objects
are noticeable, which obviously deny reality. In the end, photomanipulation is
going to constantly be around for years to come; I just hope we don’t abuse
this or get lost in it.